Parents want to think a lot about holiday gifts for their children. If you can find the perfect educational toy or cultural experience, your child could become a genius or win a soccer scholarship.
It doesn’t help when stores push “genius” toys and unforgettable experiences. But here’s what parents forget: The more we try to optimize holiday gifts for our kids, the more we miss out on the joy that’s available right now.
As a medical ethicist and mother of two, I have good news. A child’s development does not depend on finding the perfect gift. You can resist the urge to be over-specced and still do right by your family.
If you need a reset from the pressure of optimizing this holiday season, here are four overhauls to help you reduce risk, protect your play, and prioritize presence over performance.
1. There is no magic key
Endless reviews, algorithms, and AI tools make finding the perfect gift easy. If you skip hunting, you may feel like you’re not trying hard enough.
But if you zoom out, you’ll see that this is just one of hundreds of parenting decisions we’ll make this year. The impact of one small choice, such as what to buy for the holidays, outweighs all the other things that impact a child’s development and well-being. One gift does not determine the trajectory of your life.
Now we can stop searching Amazon for mystical gifts that will magically unlock our children’s potential and give them a direct path to success. Unfortunately, that’s not the case.
2. More is not necessarily better.
Chasing the best can be counterproductive if you think “best” means flashy or high-tech. When it comes to play, research shows that simple, classic toys often lead to higher quality play than complex, scripted toys. Open-ended toys leave a lot of room for imagination.
The extra stuff we want to squeeze out of “perfection” is usually not in the product itself. It’s in how we show up. Nicola Yelland, professor of early childhood studies at the University of Melbourne, said: “Any toy can be educational if you play with it and talk to children about what they’re doing and what they’re learning.”
Instead of worrying about the perfect gift, you can focus your efforts on finding the perfect gift and then receiving that gift.
3. Be a support person, not an engineer.
It’s good to want our children to learn and grow, but it’s easy to take this desire too far. When gifts and enrichment schemes are aimed at improving skills and talents, play can feel like work and its intrinsic value is undermined.
The gift of experience is also not unrelated to collective nurturing efforts. Author Faith Hill points out that family vacations are now also accompanied by growth goals. We hope that traveling abroad will help children become more adaptable, resilient and cultured. A culture of productivity permeates everywhere.
But if you stop treating every moment of your leisure time as a productive workout, you can create more space for joy, curiosity, creativity, and connection. These values are worth pursuing for their own sake, not just as a means to future achievement.
Instead of asking, “What will this do for my child?” you can ask, “What will this help my child notice, enjoy, and share now?”
4. Love is enough
Nothing we give our kids for vacation will get them into Harvard. that’s ok.
As developmental psychologist Alison Gopnik reminds us in her book The Gardener and the Carpenter, our job as parents is not to create a certain type of child or shape their destiny, but to create a space of love, safety, and stability in which they can grow.
There is no need to calculate which gifts will provide the greatest developmental benefit for the children. Vacations are an opportunity for children to feel important now. If you can do that, that’s enough.
Dr. Jen Zamzow is an adjunct professor of medical ethics at Concordia University Irvine, an author, and a mother of two boys. You can find her in her Substack newsletter, “A Well-Lived Life.”
Want to give your kids the ultimate advantage? Sign up for CNBC’s new online course, “How to Raise Financially Smart Kids.” Learn how to build healthy financial habits now to set your kids up for greater success in the future. Use coupon code EARLYBIRD for 30% off. Offer valid from December 8th to December 22nd, 2025. Terms and conditions apply.
